What market? No one else had the chance to bid on Neifury. The same thing an arbitrator would use, Geech. When a player goes to arbitration, no one is bidding on him, are they? The market is what other SSs with comparable stats are getting paid. in that case Neifi should be getting 500k/year. On the extreme low end, I agree. Angel Berroa had a .305 OBP and a .680 OPS to Neifi's .298 OBP and .681 OPS, and he made exactly $500,000 last season according to espn.com. But he also played for the Royals who had the one of the lowest payroll's last season which agent's must take into account. But then there are Orlando Cabrera (6 mil .309/.674), Jack Wilson (3.25 mil .299/.662), Alex Gonzalez of the Marlins (3.4 mil .319/.686) and Christian Guzman (4.2 mil .260/.574). There are plenty of players who had similar OBPs and OPSs that were paid less than Neifi's 2.5 million like Cesar Izturis (2.15 mil .302/.624), Alex Cora (1.3 mil and a .275/.607), and Juan Castro (1 mil .279/.665). Arbitrators also have to take into account the player's personal salary history and his most recent performance. While agent's take into account a given team's payroll and how much they can afford to spend. So there are a lot of factors that go into determining what is a fair price to pay for someone's services. Those are four horrible contracts. The players were not expected to perform as badly as they did when they were signed. Neifi is hoped to perform at the level. Nobody thinks those are good contracts. Except maybe our moron of a gm.