Bengie Molina: 295/336/446, 15 HR, 69 RBI, 41/27 K/BB, IsoP 110 Michael Barrett: 276/345/479, 16 HR, 61 RBI, 61/40 K/BB, IsoP 134 A bit bigger difference than I expected, but not much, and entirely in IsoP. Wouldn't Molina's better defense cancel out Barrett's slightly better slugging? I'm not anti-Barrett, I'm just thinking of trade currency and ways to improve the OVERALL team here. Like I said before, that was a career year for Molina. Aside from this past year, he's never had an OBP over .320, and for his career he barely cracks a .700 OPS(84 career OPS+, yikes). He'll be 32 this summer and age normally isn't too kind to catchers. If he were several years younger I'd like it alot more, and I could understand the shift to a defense oriented catcher philosophically, but I don't think switching Molina for Barrett is the way to go, unless you can get a LOT in trade for Barrett. Exactly. Molina's only had one year where he's be in the same conversation as Barrett, so unless you discover that some team hugely overvalues Michael and you can get something crazy for him, there's little chance of this improving the team.