I've been out of this debate for about 4 pages, so forgive me for catching up. Delmon Young intended one of two things...to either harm the umpire, or to make the umpire believe he was capable and likely to harm him in the future if he didn't do as he wanted. So, either he intended to harm him, or if you believe his statement that he didn't mean to hit him, then his intent was to threaten him with harm in the future the next time he made a call against him. For those who don't think he intended to cause harm but believe his teammates who say he did intend to hit him, what would any reasonable person expect to happen by throwing a bat at high velocity at someone? Any reasonable person would expect pain and suffering as a result of the throw. (and for those who insist on calling it an underhand flip, this underhand flip had about the same emphasis on it as when Kent Tekulve unhand flipped the ball to home when he was pitching.) In either case, this is severe and is not in the same ballpark as headbutting another player or spitting at an ump. Plus, he's undermining the integrity of the game by, if you believe he didn't mean to hit him, intending to intimdate the umpire so as to influence future calls. I say season ban, probation with threat of a lifetime ban in '07.