Rolen is a top 10 offensive third baseman and top 5 defensive third baseman. Are there eligible guys who deserve to be in before him? Sure. But 40? Maybe a half dozen if you exclude steroid scandal guys. I count 15 guys with 60+ WAR that aren't in who aren't eligible yet, either banned, steroids guys, from the 1800s. Lou Whitaker, Bobby Grich, Dwight Evans, and Luis Tiant are probably the biggest misses on that list. Whittaker’s absence from the Hall at this point is inexplicable. Except that a majority of the guys in that 60+ WAR range that aren’t in the Hall (and aren’t steroid guys) all played in that same 70-80s time frame. Grich, Evans and Tiant all fill the same bill. As do Reuschel, Nettles, Buddy Bell, Willie Randolph, Reggie Smith, Tommy John, Bando, and Keith Hernandez. Throw in Thurman Munson who played the same position and had a higher WAR than Campanella while dying three years younger than Campanella was when he had his career ending accident. (To be fair, Campanella didn’t make his MLB debut until age 26 due to segregation, while Munson debuted at age 22.)