What does an overachieving fofense have to do with their pyth record? Not sure what you're talking about Ryan Theriot Derosa Edmonds Johnson Fontenot All key contributers who are playing wayyyy above expectations. If those guys return to where we expected them to be, how much better is this offense than last year? Better,m but not significantly better. How about if Lee and Fukudome perform where we expected them to be? And you're overlooking a huge upgrade to the offense at catcher. It went from being a complete black hole last year to being one of the top 2 or 3 in baseball, and it wasn't totally unexpected. Lee and FUkudome? You really think it's realistic that they "snap out of it"? I don't. I think it's pretty clear by now that Fukudome is not good and Lee is declining in a big way. That's a poor example. I think it's much more likely that guys like Theriot, Derosa, and Edmonds to fall back to where they should be. Will it happen? I don't know, but it should be a concern. And I know Soto is an upograde, that's why I said the offense would still be better than 2007, just not signifcantly better. I mean, think about it. The 2007 offense was very mediocre. So what has changed since then? Soto is the one definite upgrade. Fukudome is a downgrade in RF (offesnively), Derrek Lee is performing way under his 2007 numbers, and then center field is the last position that is different. My point is that 3 of the 4 biggest upgrades (2008 Theriot over 2007 Theriot, 2008 DeRosa over 2007 DeRosa, and the CF platoon over the 2007 CF situation) could revert back to 2007 ways in an instant. ALl I'm saying is that it concerns me that on paper, this offense is very close to the 2007 offense in terms of players.