You clearly compared the 2 lineups. I'm not sure how you're going to deny that. If you weren't comparing the Cubs lineup to the Yankees lineup, then bringing it up was pointless. Nobody said an aging lineup was automatically a problem. He was clearly talking about the Cubs specifically and this group of players. So yeah, bringing up the Yankees was either a comparison to the Cubs, or it served no purpose. The Yankees old guys have produced. The original post the guy made was clearly voicing concern over how well the CUBS players would age. You know that some players can produce into their late 30's, and some can't..... right?