Pretty sure that's everyone's overall philosophy. In practice, it's not that easy and it isn't so cut and dry. Ichiro will be 39 years old when he hits FA, and could easily just retire. Do you really think he'd be getting some huge, franchise changing contract? Sabathia you're just plain wrong on. He'll decline, but despite how you might seem to imply in your posts it's very possible to do that gracefully, and it's even happened before (even recently!). I never said it hasn't happened before. It's about minimizing risk. Even if you're optimistic for our chances in the next year or 2, you should still realize that Theo's priority (and rightfully so) is what the team will look like in a few years and then continuously beyond that. Your argument is that "he might not decline", etc etc., but that's not a good way to look at it. You assess the risk involved, and the older you are, the more of a risk you are. that's pretty simple. Sure Sabathia could still be an elite pitcher in 2015, but how likely is that? I feel like signing Sabathia would be saying "by the end of this contract there's a huge chance we're going to be paying 20 mil a year to a guy with an ERA in the mid 4's" and for what? So we can be more competetive right now, with a team that probably isn't going to win anyways? I'm fine with building for both now and the future, but I don't think Sabathia fits in with building for the future, at all. I mean, what's your realistically optimistic hope with Sabathia. 3 more years as an elite pitcher? Maybe 4? And how many years will be probably get? 6 or 7? And how many of those elite years will actually come in seasons where we're ready to actually win a World Series? 1 or 2? So knowing that's what he's going to try to do here, why is he going to immediately go out and spend big money on a 31 year old pitcher who will be getting into his mid 30's by the time the Cubs hope to become a Boston type organization (legit contenders just about every year). I'm not saying Theo is going to throw out 2012 (and he shouldn't) but I don't see how you can envision him going out and throwing huge money on a guy who figures to be trending downwards around the time the organization hopes to be trending upwards. Especially considering the top SP talent that will be hitting free agency in the next couple offseasons. It's like you're excited about Theo, but all your suggestions are the types of things that this organization has been doing for years. Giving out significant money to guys who are most likely going to be declining at a point when they still have big money coming to them, and going for immediate results based on who happens to be available, instead of methodically building a team when it actually make sense. "Well, Cole Hamels and Zack Greinke may be better options than CC considering what we're tryng to build long-term here, but if we just settle for Sabathia, we can have him NOW"