Couple things here so I can distract myself from the actual game:
1. I think batting order is an easy thing to point to when you're evaluating a manager, correctly or incorrectly, just because everyone has their preference on who the best hitters are, and those guys should bat more than the less good hitters.
2. Ross, for whatever reason, has made it clear that he's only going to change his lineup like, on a monthly basis. Some guys are like that, Maddon went back and forth, whatever. I rarely think those lineups are the most effective way to group these hitters, and I think in particular it almost seems like he gives Dansby and Nico undue offensive credit when an unusually large part of their (substantial value) comes from their defense. Some hypothetical bad defensive first baseman who OPSes .830 is way less valuable than Hoerner, but he should probably get more at bats.
3. In the short run, I really don't think it matters. Suzuki with a .350 OBP is like 7% more likely to come through than Dansby with a .325 OBP, and these are made up numbers. I think the advanced stats back this up.