Well, except those will be save situations which he is good in. Which are those? It seems sort of silly to me that people think there's some sort of meaningful distinction between his relative success with 1, 2, and 3 run leads and his repeated failures in tie games. Do you think he pitches differently when the game is tied in the ninth inning than he does when it's a 1, 2, or 3 run lead in the ninth inning? The distinction is utterly absurd. Also, non-save situations aren't restricted to tie games as they include any lead over 3 runs. If you don't think a pitcher pitches differently with a big lead than he does with a 1 or 2 run lead you're crazy. If the actual facts were that Dempster had pitched poorly a number of times with an 8 run lead, your argument would make sense. That's not the case. Dempster's really poor games this season: April 22 v. StL: gave up 3 runs in a tie game in the 10th inning to lose May 17 @ NyM: gave up 5 runs after coming with 5-1 lead in the 9th Jun 10 @ Atl: gave up 3 runs to blow a 4-2 lead and lose 5-4 Aug 3 v. NYM: gave up 4 runs in the 9th after coming in to a 2-2 game Sept. 6 v. LAD: gave up 4 in the 9th to blow a 4-3 and lose 7-4 Sept. 14 v. StL: gave up 2 runs in the 9th with a 5-1 lead at StL Only 2 of those games were technically "save situations." But all but the Sept. 14 game were extremely high leverage spots. The Apr 22 and Aug 3 games were tie games in the 9th and 10th inning. The May 17 didn't start as a high-leverage game, but Dempster turned it into one quickly. It's merely coincidental that only two of his really bad games have come in "save" situations. If you think a pitcher pitches differently with a 1 or 2 run lead than he does in a tie game in the 9th or 10th inning, it's you who is crazy. You seem to have missed the part where soccer mentioned Dempster is supposed to come in with a 1-3 run lead. And in the regular season Dempster has blown 2 games so far. The games you posted backed up what soccer was saying.