Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. I like lots of the secondary left. Evans, King, and Williams are my favorite Safeties. Wilson and Awuzie are my favorite CB's left. But, there's plenty others of each I'd be fine with too. Wormley is a favorite of mine, but I'd pass on him, to add more picks. Last year, we went from 41 to 49, picking up 117 and a 2017 4th. Then moved from 49 to 56, getting 124 in return. I'd love to do the same, we'd still have some damn good players on the board, in the late 40's, early 50's. The extra 4ths would be nice too, maybe to grab a DL and a WR/TE. I like Obi and Marcus Maye at S. Evans is ultra athletic, but can't tackle for horsefeathers. I think he may be an NFL corner. King I'd take (not at 36), wish he was taller, but he's a guy that can play FS or nickel CB and he's going to play well. Great tackler too. Williams also can't tackle very well, but he'll get the job done. And if it wasn't for Malik Hooker being in this draft, people would be raving about his ball skills At CB, I like Tankersley. I think he's a 1st round talent. Very physical press coverage guy, that nobody seems to realize ran a 4.4 flat. Not sure why he wasn't more highly thought of. But yeah, I think you have to trade down and take your chances. It worked out last year with getting Whitehair in the late 2nd. I actually think Cleveland could make another move. Kizer's sitting out there. Not sure how much they like him, but they have picks 51, 52, and 65. If they can walk out of today with Garrett, Njoku, Peppers and Kizer and still have another pick (it would probably only take 51 and 65 to move to 36), they're sitting pretty.
  2. My top 10 on the board (as it relates to the Bears) going into Day 2: DL Malik McDowell S Obi Melifonwu DL Chris Wormley CB Cordrea Tankersley OT Forrest Lamp (I think you play him at LT first) OT Cam Robinson CB Kevin King S Budda Baker OLB Tim Williams WR Juju Smith-Schuster Dalvin Cook is my BPA, but the Bears aren't taking a RB (then again, I didn't think they'd mortgage 2 potential starters to move up 1 pick). The Bears probably also aren't taking the 36th pick, as I think they trade back to recoup a 3rd. So, whatever.
  3. Cleveland gonna trade both Texans 1s for Garoppolo. They are raping the Texans this offseason.
  4. This logic is bad. Good NFL prospect and good college QB (especially in a spread scheme) is not close to comparable. Hell, maybe the best QB in NFL history couldn't beat out Brian Griese in college. Sure, if you use the outlier rather than the vast vast majority of successful NFL QB's, your logic is sound My logic is Marquise Williams was the prototype college gimmicky spread QB. He ran for several hundred yards and threw in an offense that didn't require him to read a defense. He won 10 games in 2015. It happens all the time.
  5. This logic is bad. Good NFL prospect and good college QB (especially in a spread scheme) is not close to comparable. Hell, maybe the best QB in NFL history couldn't beat out Brian Griese in college.
  6. Don't take the 1st QB off the board with 1 pick, but take the 4th QB off the board using 3 picks? So, they take the 1st QB off the board AND use 3 picks to get him.
  7. Don't take the 1st QB off the board with 1 pick, but take the 4th QB off the board using 3 picks?
  8. Some interesting calls late in the game that kept the Bulls from going away with that game. But this was the 1st round matchup I wanted once I figured the Bulls would get in. Celtics are good, but not unbeatable. No chance against the Cavs. Hell, I don't think they could beat Atlanta or Washington either, but since they're in, the Bulls might as well do something with it.
  9. The Bears didn't keep Hoyer, because Hoyer sucks, has always sucked, and will never be good enough. I personally think Glennon won't be good enough either, but at least there's a chance he is. Glennon gives Fox his veteran QB so he feels like he's not rebuilding at 60-whatever years old. But it also gives Pace a guy who could potentially win some games and be a long-term option. You know there's no guarantee Kizer is there in the 2nd, right? You also know that if Kizer is the 4th or 5th QB taken in this draft, the odds are favorable that he plays like the 4th or 5th best QB in the draft class, which is to say, not very good. And while the 2018 very well may be better, the Bears aren't likely to be in the same position next year. They were pretty miserable last year and still weren't good enough to get one of the 1st 2 picks. With more health, better talent on the defensive side, a more stable QB (3 guys started 5 times last year)....the Bears are likely to pick outside of the top 10 (like they did just a year ago, before they traded to 9). So, even if this class is great, you're probably not going to have the 1 or 2 pick to get Darnold or Allen unless you trade multiple 1st round picks to trade up, which we have seen doesn't turn out well. If you stay put because this class is so great, you're still looking at the 4th or 5th best QB in the draft. You know who else was the 4th and 5th best QBs? Rex Grossman and Cade McNown. I don't understand why if you acknowledge the Bears need a QB, why you are intentionally willing to hope to have a shot at the 4th best guy when you are in the prime position to take the top QB in the draft. I understand BPA and all that, but this isn't DE vs. CB. This is by far the most important position in any sport.
  10. I've thought this every year Grimm's been here. Grimm, Montgomery and Rondon are the non-setup relievers, right now. That's a half decent 7-8-9 inning for a lot of teams. And still have 1 of Strop/Uehara who wouldn't get in the last 3 innings if all went right.
  11. Newsflash:. The Cubs are ridiculously good from the hole at SS to the 1b/RF bleachers when Almora, Heyward, and Baez are on the field together.
  12. I believe raw has a Bears blog so it might make sense for him to compile something like this. Had. Now I write a little for a Bears website.
  13. Seems like a good day to break out one of my World Series champions t-shirts.
  14. Eh. All of this likely means nothing. I have a spreadsheet of players the Bears have "met" with over the last several years. In 2016, they met with Hackenberg, Prescott, Hogan, Kessler, Lynch, Cook, Brissett, and Brandon Allen and obviously didn't pick any QB. 2015, they met with all the top pass rushers (Fowler, Beasley, Gregory, Ray, Harold, Dupree) and went WR in the 1st. They did meet with Floyd and Whitehair last year of the guys they drafted, but also had meetings on 3 separate occasions with Shaq Lawson and then traded up for a guy that plays the same position. Side note, I'm starting to think OJ Howard helps this team more than any other offensive player in this draft (other than hitting on the top QB). His run blocking is amazing. He's a potentially elite pass catcher. If you want to grind it out with Jordan Howard and give Glennon some protection and a nice safety valve, OJ Howard's the best man for the job. Wouldn't take him at #3 overall, but trade down and he's definitely got to be in the conversation.
  15. I like the hire. Two solid hires for U of I and IU. Yeah, I'm good with the hire. Best of the realistic options. Now to see who leaves early, transfers, or decommits. Hopefully there are none of the latter 2. I assume Bryant goes and hope, Blackmon's sorry ass is gone.
  16. I don't understand why this keeps being a point of emphasis for you guys. It makes no sense to me. You don't like the QB class, but you acknowledge the need to take one. But you are advocating taking what would likely be the 3rd or 4th QB off the board w/ a trade down or waiting a round? That makes no sense. If you can't separate the QBs enough to figure out which one is the best, you don't just take whatever one is left when other teams pick their guy. You actually have to figure out which one is the best and take him. That's how you end up with Rex Grossman and Cade McNown. Actually, I'm perfectly fine taking one in 4-7. And its entirely possible that we either 1) value them all closely or 2) don't like any of them. If you value them all closely and think you are forced to take one early this year, adding another potential impact player with a second round pick IS worth a lot, especially when its not even definite that the guy you have ranked 1st will even be off the board when you pick. You sound like Kyle back when he was disappointed we didn't give Schwarber full slot value in the draft. Sometimes you can get your guy AND get more with it too. Plus, a trade down doesn't even guarantee that a QB is off the board yet. And anyway, if San Fran takes a QB at 2, then YOU may not be getting your top guy even if you stay at 3. You still taking a QB then, with your thoughts? I hope we wait until 2018. Saying "they're all close together" is a cop out. They won't end up close in the NFL, unless they are all bad. But history shows that doesn't happen very much. At least one of these guys is going to be a solid QB. If the Bears pick the 3rd or 4th QB because "they were all closely ranked" and he sucks..... that will be of 0 consolation. They are not going to be close to equal in the end. At least one will be clearly better. The Bears have to find that one. The best way to find that one is to take that one, not take the one teams give them by default. The problem with waiting til 2018 is you don't even know what the 2018 class will look like. Rosen, Darnold, Allen and Jackson could all stay in school, since none are seniors. And obviously, injury and regression could come into play. Then you've made yourself potentially desperate again at the position for a class led by Luke Falk. Oh and you probably get a little luckier with health and progression this year to just win enough have to put you out of reach of the top QBs. So you're back with the issue of getting your choice of a picked over QB class. If SF takes a QB, then I still won't be happy because either Watson or Trubisky will still be there. Id accept passing more if no QB goes #2.
  17. I don't understand why this keeps being a point of emphasis for you guys. It makes no sense to me. You don't like the QB class, but you acknowledge the need to take one. But you are advocating taking what would likely be the 3rd or 4th QB off the board w/ a trade down or waiting a round? That makes no sense. If you can't separate the QBs enough to figure out which one is the best, you don't just take whatever one is left when other teams pick their guy. You actually have to figure out which one is the best and take him. That's how you end up with Rex Grossman and Cade McNown.
  18. Interesting way to look at it (re: #3). I think a couple things could save Pace. 1. Fox is old. He's young. Can save a lot of face by having Fox "retire" after the season. Then can put a lot of blame on the pressure to get a veteran QB in Fox's last year(s). 2. He could have a 3rd decent draft, while not having much to show for it record-wise. If Pace can go into the offseason boasting Goldman, Floyd, Whitehair, a potential future QB and 2 other promising players from the 2017 draft, and then get something out of White and maybe Hall shows some more promise....he could have an argument to keep his job.
  19. I really just feel like the Bears are trying to copy the Cubs. Pace has been so deliberate with his rebuild that he has to have some reassurance from ownership that it's fine to take his time. The McCaskeys aren't really risking a financial hit by not being good. Their profits are essentially guaranteed with the league shared television revenue. The season tickets are sold and they don't have any reliance on walk up sales or ratings. The McCaskeys see that the Ricketts took a minimal PR hit as the team stumbled for years while rebuilding. They view themselves in the same mold as the Tisch/Mara/Rooney blue blood ownership of the Giants and Steelers and the thing that ties them together (besides mating) is longterm stability in the front office and head coach. With that they also want to be the opposite of the "new money" types like Haslam and Snyder who they probably view as making a mockery of storied franchises with their constant turmoil. They probably think Pace is their Theo and will give him as long as possible before moving on and will probably give him every opportunity to either win with Fox, or select his new head coach like Theo got to take a run at Madden after the Sveum/Renteria years. If year 3 is a 5-11 year, obviously Pace is doing a horrible job, consider the vast differences between MLB talent procurement and timing and the NFL's draft and play right away situation. But my guess is nobody in the McCaskey family cares. I've heard rumors that Fox has been basically guaranteed a 4th year. Which actually makes some amount of sense because you're likely going to draft a QB and don't want him switching staffs after his 1st year. Which obviously would mean Pace is guaranteed at least a 4th year. I don't want to be one of those teams that fires coaches and GMs after just 2-3 years, but I more don't want this. They had stagnation for years. Now it's utter failure. They were a 6-7 win team on paper last year that won 3. I agree this team has 5-11 written all over it on paper for 2017. Any underachievement and I don't see how you can justify keeping a HC after consecutive 12+ loss seasons. MAYBE Pace's job is safe if he pulls a few more promising players out of this draft, with 1 being a QB. But results need to start happening.
  20. This was the right pick. I didn't consider him for whatever reason before I made my comment.
  21. Cardinals select their QB of the future: Patrick Mahomes II, Texas Tech.
  22. How many teams weigh 8 players equally enough to trade out of a spot where they could draft their #1, even for more pucks? Didn't mean to imply that the Bears would have all 8 rated the same. Just to paint the picture of what the team would be looking at to draft.
  23. Yes, Williams probably a better compliment to Sammy Watkins, I guess.
×
×
  • Create New...