Hester and Maclin aren't even close to the same player though. Maclin is an actual WR. He's got great speed and great hands, along with being an intelligent player and solid route runner. Hester isn't a WR. He can't catch and he all he can run is a slant and a streak. Maclin's gotten this rep that he's similar to Hester, when he really isn't. He's a talented WR who just happens to be a talented returner as well. And I'd take Crab over Maclin too, but there's no way Crabtree falls to us.