Exactly. Anyone ever heard of Ty Cobb? You know, First guy ever inducted into the hall of fame.... lets talk about some of the things he did: Spiked people One time, gashed the entire back of a mans leg open by spiking He SHARPENED his spikes as to have them inflict more damage He broke a womans (she was a member of his family) nose w/ a baseball bat Beat both of his wives Abandoned his children Claimed to kill (with the butt/scope of a gun) a man who tried to mug him, and from all accounts he's telling the truth Tried to kill a hotel manager when he was told to quiet down, others were sleeping. Carried a gun, and beleived it was his *right* to use it on anyone that pissed him off... The list goes on. . Yet Pete Rose isn't in for gambling, more MLB hypocrisy. In Cobb's defense, when he killed the guy it was in self defense, the thugs who jumped him on his way to the stadium did stab him several times in the back causing serious wounds. Cobb refused to see a doctor and played later that day with blood staining the back of his jersey, several newspapers at the time confirmed this story, and Cobb in the early 60's showed Al Stump his wounds on his back when Stump questioned him about the incident. But ya, Cobb was a serious douche-bag....nevertheless, he was one of the top 5 greatest players ever in my opinion. http://www.cmgworldwide.com/baseball/cobb/images/C5.jpg Cobb is an extreme example, though a good one. Still, one doesn't need to bring up Ty Cobb to illustrate why keeping Sosa out of the hall for purely personality reason is hypocritical. This is professional sports circa 2006. The egos flying around your average clubhouse are pretty enormous. Sammy was certainly one of them. But check the average year's hall of fame class. Many of these guys had their moments----many were downright incorrigible. I just don't think personal dislike for somebody should be the deciding factor, which it appears to be for at least some of the voters. By the way, a reasonably strong argument can be made that personal dislike on the part of many voters is what keeps Ronnie Santo out of the hall. I believe that's wrong as well.