What is your opinion based on? Ethier slaughtered AA pitching in his first go round and continued to mash in the fall league. Pinto on the other hand was in his second tour of Duty in AA and showed last year he was unable to handle AAA batters. Ethier takes walks and hits for power at a league appropriate age. The same level and the same age at which Pinto put up great numbers as a pitcher. (Technically, Pinto is a few months younger than Ethier and put up similarly good numbers in 2004.) Yes, Pinto stuggled in his brief AAA callups, but the fact remains he's had just as much success at as high a level as Ethier has managed to reach all at a younger age. Ethier only managed a .686 OPS in his AAA callup, but that doesn't mean I'd write off his success at lower levels based on 17 PA just as I wouldn't write off Pinto because of his struggles in 30 AAA innings. Ethier projects to be a poor man's version of Murton (from the LH side), his power was increased due to the Texas League, if you put him in the SL, his power would've dropped. I don't think he's anything special, plus he's behind Putnam and Herrera as far as Oak. OF prospects. I'd rank Pinto higher as well.