It's a good roster, and BP is right about the bench. It's very solid. Realistically, you absolutely need a 4th starter just in case Zambrano goes long in Game 1, doesn't feel ready for Game 4, there's a long extra inning game, or someone gets injured -- whatever. You can argue that perhaps Marshall should be on the roster over Marquis, and you might be right, but it's not a clear-cut call. I suspect that perhaps the preference for the veteran over the rookie made an appearance here. As for Fontenot, he's an extra MI, which gives maximum flexibility. You don't need 6 OF's, and there's no way you're going to go into a playoff series with only one extra infielder (not counting Ward, who is primarily a PH). Moreover, this gives Lou the ability to PH, PR or double switch and have a competent replacement on hand. I'm not happy with Fontenot's approach of late (who is?), but he's the right choice to ensure that Lou has the in-game flexibility he needs. Monroe, on the other hand, gives nothing off the bench that Murton doesn't do better. While I'm not a huge fan of Jones against lefties, if there's not a capable right-handed CF to allow for a platoon, then Jones is the best option. And Monroe is a butcher out there, and not what I would call capable. I think this is the right series of calls by Lou and Jim, and I applaud their rational, realistic, and logical approach to constructing the playoff roster.