I'm disappointed, but largely fine with this outcome, given the circumstances.
In early September I was expecting the team to roll over and immediately die in the playoffs. Boyd looked gassed, Shota looked gassed, Palencia was hurt, Tucker was essentially dead, and PCA and Seiya were zombies.
Seiya and PCA woke up a bit and hopes went up, but Horton got hurt and hopes went back down.
And some days I almost forget our presumptive ace/co-ace missed essentially the entire season. I think we did pretty well in the postseason, all things considered. I'm bummed, but not as exponentially less than a Brewers fan would be if the roles were reversed right now, I think.
As for the offseason, my irrational meatball brain isn't sure about Tucker at this point. I can see him going the route of Bryant - gets hurt, can't play hurt. He's great when he's healthy, but...yeah. But I do think we saw the value of a Tucker-level hitter anchoring the lineup when he was going well. He was a catalyst for sure, and there's not another player of his (potential) caliber on the market, and I don't think he's gonna get the $500M it looked like he might a few months ago.
Not that it matters because PTR won't pay him anyway.
I don't want to see Seiya go, but mostly because I just like him. I know room should be made for on of the OF prospects, but I'd honestly rather it be Happ. I think the bottom might fall out there any minute now.
I think Busch is a legit dude, but Shaw is not, even completely setting aside that he's an 80 grade pos chud. He just looked like a child among men for like 90% of the season/postseason. Hi peripherals offer little hope and his exit velos are tragic. His Savant page is a tale of woe and misery. I might deal him while he has a whiff top prospect cache remaining.
That said, not much on the 3B market but Bregman, but maybe a run at Murakami/Okamoto (though I know there are defensive concerns there)?
But I have a bad feeling we're just going to see them largely run the offense back with one of Caissie/Alacantara in place of Tucker.
I also like the idea of a trade for Joe Ryan. The FA market for pitching is pretty uninspiring. Not sure about deal Jamo away, but he has value and I would like to see a starter with some legit velo brought in to contrast with the rest of our largely soft tossing rotation.