If I can nitpick, are they? I mean, they have undeniably pitched well, and I believe in a couple of those guys to various extents, but I'm also getting a bit of a first half Brewers offense vibe. There's some indicators that make it at least somewhat sustainable, but color me extremely skeptical that Zack Godley is going to run a .256 BABIP going forward. I do like the half of their offense that is good though, and it doesn't take much to tip a playoff series. I just don't know if the roster design is particularly well suited for upsetting one of the 3 divisional mainstays. EDIT: They also just started a brutal back half schedule. 16 games in August against the Cubs, Dodgers, and Astros. September is a bit better with only 10 against the Rockies and Dodgers(and none after 9/15), but if one of the Central teams gets hot I could see their wild card seat getting pretty hot by the last 2 weeks of the season. I do think if the DBacks get in they are a tough out. But now that I'm going through some data, they have a 72 teams wRC+ against lefties, which is the worst in baseball so that probably doesn't bode well if they get the privilege. But, since that is park adjusted we can look at wOBA, and nope they're still terrible at .294. Their team slash line against lefties is .232/.301/.389. I'd feel better about them getting lucky and beating a Kershaw or Hill if they didn't have to burn Greinke in the WCG.