Fukudome's D > Fontenot's bat. As good as Fontenot's bat has been, he can't be expected to OPS .900 for the duration of the playoffs - he's already fallen pretty far off that pace over the course of August and September. Even at Fukudome's worst, he'll work the count and pick up a walk here and there. He's not hurting the lineup a great deal if he's in the #8 spot, and if he catches one ball that would have otherwise fallen in for a double with an average RF in his place - happens much more often than you'd think - he's helping the team. Pitching wins championships, and a great defense turns good pitching performances into great ones - the '07 Rockies are a great example. There's no reason a rotation fronted by Jeff Francis and Ubaldo Jimenez should've been within sniffing distance of the playoffs, but when you give them one of the best defenses of the last ten years, they're good enough to win an NL title.