Your car analogy doesn't apply to the situation. Try this one: If you bought a car and it broke down and ended up being unrepairable, would you let it sit in your garage taking up space that could be better used by one of your other cars? Or if you had an offer to give you a small amount of money to get rid of that car, wouldn't you take it even though it may be well below what you owe? The problem with your analogy is that no one offered us anything. They agreed to take him if we pay them to do so. Sometimes you have to pay to have the garbage taken away. I know that. This isn't one of them though. I think in the AL, JJ could have some value as a LH DH. Paying to give him away is not the best option. Edit: And I'm not against picking up some of his salary but not 90% over the next year and a half.