Your eyes deceive you. Those "easy" plays that Cedeno is botching? Theriot isn't even able to get to a lot of those balls on his best days. It isn't really fair to ding Cedeno for a play that Theriot wouldn't have made either. 1.) Theriot is the worst hitter on this team. Leadoff hitters get the most PA of any person on the team. Logically, there is no conceivable way that you can defend Theriot batting leadoff. None. The worst hitter on the team should not be the one we send to the plate most often, not in any circumstance. 2.) RBI's mean almost nothing. 3.) Wouldn't Theriot getting better pitches to hit be a bad thing? He doesn't have enough power to do any real damage with them... and if the pitchers are making sure not to walk Theriot, his offensive value is lower than Cedeno's floor. 1. How does Cedeno get to balls Theriot can't? Theriot is every bit as quick as Cedeno. And really where were all these Cedeno defense fans up until a month or two ago. 2. Pie is a worse hitter right now than Theriot. Does he has the potential to be better, of course, but he has yet to show it in the bigs. 3. RBIs mean nothing??? Sure it doesn't matter who gets them, but Soriano batting with a guy on base is much better than Theriot and just about everyone else on this team. This is why I'm not going crazy about Theriot being leadoff. Would I prefer a better hitter, sure, but we all know if Theriot isn't leadoff Soriano would be with Lou. Would you rather Soriano get on base and then Theriot try to bat him in or Theriot get on base and Soriano try and bat him in? 4. Getting better pitches isn't mall about hitting homeruns. Thats just the same as saying hitting is all about getting homeruns. If Theriot sees better pitches that means he will get more hits. Will they be homeruns? No like you say he doesn't have the power for it, but his average would likely be higher.