Like most everyone else, if salary is included, then Theriot. Jeter's production has never been worth $20 million and it never will be. I don't care how captainy or clutchy he is. There's only a handful of men in the majors who are worth $20+ million. Derk Jeter is not, and never has been, one of them. I'll take the gritty spark plug entering his prime (though that's not saying much for Theriot) at $428,000 over the aging, overpaid, and vastly overrated superstar at $20 million. If salary is not an issue, you take Jeter obviously, but salary is always an issue, and this makes it quite an easy decision to avoid Jeter and his declining skillset.