Fair enough False. He was nowhere near one of the 10 best pitchers in the AL his first year. Nor was he in his 2nd year. Or his 3rd. He was the 10th best pitcher by fWAR in his 4th full season (his 5th year as a Royal). He was 8th best pitcher by fWAR in his final year as a Royal. So he was one of the 10 best pitchers in the AL for the final 3 of his 7 total years as a Royal. Not sure what the point is you're trying to make with that statement. See #2. His insane 2009 (9.3 fWAR) allowed him to be listed as the most valuable pitcher between 2008-2010 in the AL (the only time frame when he was considered a Top 10 pitcher in the league). He was 4th most valuable in both AL and NL, behind Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee, and Tim Lincecum. If you want to extend that all the way to his rookie year, he was the 8th most valuable pitcher during his AL stint from 2004-2010. He was out fWAR'd in the AL by C.C Sabathia, Roy Halladay, John Lackey, Mark Beuhrle, Johan Santana, and Felix Hernandez. If you extend that to both NL and AL, he was 13th most valuable in that time frame. Other pitchers who get put in front of him include Javier Vasquez, Roy Oswalt, Dan Haren, Brandon Webb, and Josh Beckett. No, they really weren't.