You should meet my friend, Mr. Facts. Hmmm, Mr. Facts shows that out of 8 seasons for Drew, 4 of them were seriously hampered due to injury and 2 others were less than 140 games. That's what is known in the real universe as a player with injury problems. Minus breaking his wrist last year due to being HBP -- which can't really be attributed to being injury prone, I think -- he's been fairly healthy the last three years. Okay, well you can't just look at the past 3 years and ignore the first 5. Especially when last year he missed time (although a fluke injury). IIRC he was also injured some in 2005. Didn't miss a ton of time but had some sort of injury. I will say that he gets minor injuries fairly often, but 145 games of Drew > Soriano IMO. Without the broken wrist last year, I imagine he ends up between 140 and 150 games. I'm pretty sure I'm not alone in looking at 3 year trends rather than a whole career. But how can you look at a 3 year trend when you can't even look at one of the years? You can't just say if he didnt break his wrist he wouldn't have gotten hurt some other way. He's shown a tendency to get injured. He's gotten 500 ABs or more once in 8 years. Despite all this I would rather have Drew than Soriano, but I can see why JH would be worried to bank on J.D. staying healthy and saving his job.