I dont think anyone ever really saw Reed as anything more than a platoon guy vs. lefties or a late inning defensive sub. there may not have been a lot on this board, there were a ton of stupid cubs fans wanting him to play against righties at several times during his cubs career. Reed Johnson had a lot of support from people I know to become an everyday player. During some of Kosuke's slumps, I recall some on the board wanting Reed to start everyday. In their defense, Im not a Kosuke basher, but when he is in one of his slumps, there arent a lot of guys who I wouldnt rather have come to the plate. As for a lot of Cubs fans supporting Reed as an everyday player, in his short time as a Cub Reed did estblish himself as a "fan favorite", and in those cases, your average fan will look past the fact that hes inept vs. righties. Look at Ryan Theriot. While Im not a Theriot basher or a Theriot lover, I know a lot of people on this board are Theriot bashers, but as far as your average fan goes, hes a fav as well, and many people see him as a Cub for life.