Because Pena/Kotchman/Loney are the only alternatives if you don't sign Pujols/Fielder. Who did you have in mind? For 2012, pretty much as far as known available options, that's pretty much all I can think of. If Miguel Cabrera or Justin Morneau suddenly become available, then great. It's a little easier if you try to think of options that wouldn't be preferable to LaHair. The answer is most everyone. LaHair is not good, and even if a miracle happens and he's okay then you're still stuck with a 30 year old that has one year under his belt and you're back where you started. If you can't find someone with a better long term prognosis than that, then you're an embarrassment of a baseball executive. Of course you can, but there's really no rush to do it now. Without Pujuls or Fielder, unless they pull of some maverick series of moves 2012 will be junked, so just go with the free guy you have and don't waste any resources on a plan C. Even if they are better than LaHair, and I'm not denying that they would be but they wouldn't be enough of an upgrade to make what we have now resemble a contender or even a 70 win team. With Pujola or Fielder, you maybe have a .500 team for 2012 if your lucky and if enough things go right that didn't last year. With LaHair, Pena, Kotchman, Loney, Cuddyer, or any alternate realistic options you have a bandaid and I'd just assume go with the cheapest one possible if it's going to yield the same end result. May as well give the chance to become another Ryan Ludwick and if he becomes Micah Hoffpauir, oh well. Without any big acquisitions, my plan for 2012 will be to follow Castro, Jackson, Garza, Cashner and the farm and any wins we pick up along the way will be gravy.