Okay using my system using this lineup (most of the time) Name, POS - PT% 1. Soriano, LF - 90% 2. Fukudome, RF - 90% 3. Lee, 1B - 90% 4. Ramirez, 3B - 80% 5. DeRosa, 2B - 75% 6. Soto, C - 66% 7. Theriot, SS - 75% 8. Pie, CF - 90% predicts 811.5 Runs Scored which shows: RA - Wins 700 - 91.8 720 - 89.7 750 - 86.8 With the trade, this: 1. Roberts 90% 2. Fukudome 90% 3. Lee 90% 4. Ramirez 80% 5. Soriano 90% 6. Soto 66% 7. Theriot 75% 8. Pie 90% predicts 825.2 runs: 700 93.0 720 90.9 750 88.0 so a 13.8 run increase and about 1.2 win increase. Not significant by any stretch of the imagination. Using Marshall as an SP and leaving Dempster in the pen ought to move our projected runs allowed from ~750 to ~725. It's a better scenario. Vote no on Roberts.