Not exactly a new topic, but Rob Neyer has an article about how horrible the IBB is. It seemed like just whining for a while, but there's some suggestions at the end, and they don't come from Rob. This one sounds interesting, from A Game of Inches... The suggestion is that the first time a four pitch walk happened, it would be just like a normal walk. After that, a rule such as the above would take effect. It would allow the managers to "save" an IBB for a strategic moment, presuming their pitcher didn't accidentally waste it. Other ideas in the article... http://mlb.sbnation.com/2011/10/25/2512355/intentional-walks-the-scourge-of-the-game