Not when they had previously ruled the play dead. I mean, the rule on the books(as silly as I think it is) was correct for Odor to score there, so the end result isn't super unjust, but umpire calling a play dead killing everything that's ongoing is not a fact that it's in doubt. Unless you have a replay review, the umpire's ruling is an eraser to anything that could be considered in progress. This. Much more eloquent than my reasoning. The Blue Jays’ other defense was that because the umpire called time before Rougned Odor came in to score, the play should have been dead. But umpires award bases on dead balls all the time, when it’s obvious that the runner would have reached it without a fuss. http://deadspin.com/i-still-cant-believe-the-rangers-nearly-won-on-that-pla-1736691888 Not that deadspin is some ultimate authority on the topic or anything, but I happen to think they're right.