The Cy Young award isn't handed out to the pitcher who you would want on the mound in a big game, it's handed out to the pitcher who pitched the best over the course of the whole season. So far, Webb and Carpenter have pitched better than Zambrano. I'm not saying I would pick either of those two over Z in a big game, but fact is they have pitched better than Z this year. Will they continue to? Who knows. But if the Cy Young was handed out today, Z would not win it. I can respect that analysis, but I wouldn't say that Zambrano would not win it. He is definately in the running, especially after winning 8 straight, with as many wins, and leading the NL in strikeouts.