I guess you just didn't look at the numbers. His "clutch" stats aren't routinely better than his regular stats. Sometimes they are a little better, sometimes a little worse, and in the case of this year, his close and late are much worse. He's the same hitter virtually all the time. And that's a very good hitter. So, when you give a very good hitter lots of opportunities to have a bit clutch hits, which is what a great team with great team OBP will give a guy, you will have numerous instances where he'll come through. You'll also have a lot of times when he'll fail, just like every ballplayer has lots of times when they fail. In what universe is .326 .408 .724 worse than 297 .383 .600? Runners on and risp you know he'll have a higher OBP/lower slg. And that's not "sometimes", that's "every year you posted" In 2006 his close and late are worse than his overall. In 2003, for instance, he was better with nobody on than with people on. In 2004, that was reveresed. He tends to have much worse numbers with a man on third than in any other situation, kind of weird. The guy is a really good hitter, and he plays for a team where you are going to have a lot of opportunities to do something notable. And he usually hits in front of one of the best hitters in baseball.