He has already stated that he felt terrible and that he blew the biggest call of his career. I think people need to cut the guy some slack. http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/recap?gid=300602106 Why should he be cut slack? It wasn't even a close play. It's didn't even qualify as a "bang bang" play. The runner was clearly out. There was no question. You didn't need slow motion replay to see it. The ump's head was up his ass. That's a complete and utter failure at your job. The only way to miss that is if you, as the umpire, are completely unfocused and paying no attention whatsoever to what is going on in front of you - to what should be your ONLY focus at that moment. Joyce's job at that point, no, his DUTY to Gallaraga, The Tigers, the game of baseball, the fans in the stadium, is to GET THE CALL RIGHT. He failed utterly and completely. It's like Michael Jordan hitting the game winning three pointer with 3 seconds left on the clock in Game Seven and the ref saying time expired before the shot drained. It's that big of a failure. He shouldn't be cut slack. He should be sent back to double A ball where he belongs, and he should stop by the DMV on the way to get his vision checked. These atrocious umpires need to be held accountable. Screw steroids, the state of umpiring is the biggest threat to the integrity of the game of baseball today. I agree 100% This guy needs zero slack....he needs fired Joyce is getting paid a lot of money to do his job right and he has consistently f'ed up this year and f'ed up big time today Fire him period...do not cut him any slack Until the umps are held accountable the umpiring will continue to be shitty and an embarrassment to the sport