I can't see how "we're still sub .500 but have a top 10 farm system with several of his draft picks and acquired prospects filtering through and contributing at the big league level, then he still comes off looking pretty good" makes sense. He was hired to a 5-year contract to win a WS (or at least get us to the WS and be a solid, perennial contender). This is the biggest market team in a weak, winnable division and Theo was given complete autonomy. If this team is still below .500 next year, then we need to realize we've been sold some snake oil. "Sold some snake oil?" What? They're not trying to trick or scam anyone. He's getting at Epstein and Co. being viewed as scam artist. A Harold Hill/The Great Oz type. To play devils advocate, if anyone was "selling snake oil" it would be Ricketts. He's the one who jumped through so many hoops to get Epstein as his big signing. Epstein just accepted the un-refuseable offer. Everyone assumed that he'd do pretty much what Jim Hendry would have done; launched buckets of money at Pujols, Ramirez, Darvish, Wilson, and anyone else within range as well as produce our own Pedroia, Lester, Ellsbury, etc. Meanwhile, the fact that Epstein inherited a perenial 90 game winner to build off of didn't seem to register. As I recall, Epstein spent that entire off season preaching that he wabnted to go young, and we probably wouldn't be where we want to be for several years, but fans chose to ignore that, expecting him to Ninja Albert Pujols or Prince Fielder for a 3/75 contract. Again, not his fault. If anything, his chosen route isn't to scam anyone so much as do what Andrew Friedman did; create a team that when all is said and done is 100% his. A monument to himself so to speak. Depending on how the next 2 drafts turn out, whether or not he stays or goes when his contract expires, that's pretty much what he'll have done. You're saying, like, 28 different things with this post.