Dusty does take a lot of abuse. And, to a certain extent, this is a bit of hard luck, because as TT pointed out earlier, when a manager does things right, it pretty much just means that they've made the obviously correct decision (i.e., didn't screw up), and so don't get much praise for it, but when a manager does something wrong, it's usually picked apart, because it tends to be a pretty obviously stupid thing to do. So it's generally a pretty thankless job. BUT - that's the same for every manager everywhere, and that doesn't change the fact that an extraordinary amount of Dusty's decisions are exceptionally, frustratingly, mind-bogglingly stupid. He can't construct a lineup to save his life. He gives terrible, terrible players FAR too much playing time, all the while allowing more promising and/or more capable players to rot on the bench. He's never met a pitcher that he can't misuse, reliever or starter (well, he's still working on Maddux, but that's about it). So while Dusty does bring some very good things to the table (some players - and I emphasize some - really like him, for example, and that is a good thing), he still deserves most of the criticism that he gets on this board.