i'm perfectly fine with this, but the bench might be too optimistic you already factored in Castillo, so you're left with: Tommy La Stella Chris Coghlan Justin Ruggiano Ryan Sweeney i actually like TLS more than most, but Coghlan, Ruggiano, Sweeney are basically replacement level; i think you've almost got to be happy to break even with this group, maybe top out at 1 WAR if you think Maddon works platoon magic or whatever