If one assumes that we take four strikers, and Jozy and Charlie are healthy, that leaves 6 guys for two spots: -Ching and Casey for the holdup/target role. Ching is more experienced and tactically stronger. He's been the lone striker in our 4-5-1/4-3-3 hybrid setup. Casey is stronger and get himself into scoring positions more frequently (i.e., I think his off-the-ball positioning and runs are better) but he's slow as hell and a poor finisher. Ching is better defensively and Casey better offensively. -Buddle, Gomez and EJ for the backup striker role. Buddle is the most physically gifted of all three, and the biggest headcase. EJ is EuroBuddle, has pace but poor tactical acumen. Gomez plays in the softest defensive league of the three, but leads said league in scoring. Buddle is better in the air, Gomez an better poacher and EJ better on the counter. -Adu is the least likely of the group to go, sees the least amount of tick, but is the most likely to be able to break a bunker and provide a moment of genius. LD and CD8's flexibility help us here. Deuce can play the holdup role late in games, eliminating the need for Ching or Casey. LD can play the backup striker role if need be. Their flexibility opens the possibility of using the 23rd spot on Adu, however unlikely it may be. I wouldn't take a forward based on his ability to defend within the setup, but Bob will. The May camp will clear this up, but if it were me, today, I take: Jozy Chuck D Buddle Adu. Buddle can back up Chuck D, CD8 can back up Jozy and Adu can be used to break Slovenia and Algeria's bunker. If we are 1-1 in the 65th minute and need a goal to advance against ALG, do you really want our bench options to be Casey/EJ/Ching? That would be disastrous. We should only take 7 defenders and three keepers. That leaves 9 MF's and 4 strikers. The 8th defender taken to the past 4 WC's by the US has never played. With Spector and Bornstein able to fill central and wing spots, we should not take a 7th defender. The defenders should be: Gooch (CB) Boca (CB/FB) Demerit (CB) Bornstein (CB/FB) Spector (CB/FB) Goodison (CB) Cherundolo (FB) The mids: Donovan (LM) Dempsey (RM) Bradley (CM) Edu (CM/CB) Holden (RM) Torres (CM/RM) Clark (CM) Bedoya (LM) Feilhaber (CM/RM) It's the defender pool which worries me far more than the forward group. If Gooch isn't ready to go, we're in deep trouble. We'll have to bring a player like Marshall or Conrad, both of whom aren't international quality, or play Boca centrally which I'm not keen on, or have Goodison pair with Demerit, but defenders collect cards, and our central defender depth will be tricky. If Gooch is ready, forget the 9th MF, since Bradley would almost certainly forget Adu or anyone else in that 4th FWD spot, add Dempsey to the forward group and bring Pearce along with the Marshall/Conrad/Gibbs/Gonzalez choice at CB. Our offensive ability will be hampered by that, and our defensive quality would be pretty poor. Gooch's health will trigger more worrisome decisions than Davies' in the end.