Yes, I'm pretty sure that I read that batting order is essentially meaningless. That's overstating it just a bit. If you run today's lineup through a simulator, you'll see there's about a one-run difference between the best possible order and the worst possible order. However, no manager, not even one as inept as Dusty, will ever pencil in the worst possible batting order (ie, pitcher hitting first, etc). Are you sure it's that much? It can be as much as a 2 run differential (if I understand you right)? I really don't recall the particulars of what I read and couldn't find anything doing a quick google search. Do you have a link? I've got to go to a business meeting, but here's a nice toy to play with: http://www.baseballmusings.com/cgi-bin/LineupAnalysis.py It's crude, but it gives you an idea of how much (or how little) batting order matters.