OK....I'm trying very, very, very, hard not to cheat because this is bothering me a great deal, and considering how much I love that era of baseball, I really want to know the answer. Power hitting contemporaries of Simmons and Herman and it isn't Ott, Greenberg, or Hack Wilson... the only ones I can think of: If none of those is right then I'm out, because I really can't think of anyone else back in that time that I remember as having somewhat significant power. EDIT: I just remembered another and wanted to add his name to my dying effort to name 1920-30's sluggers (remembered him from "The Glory of Their Times"): I'm pretty sure he had over 30 homers a couple of times.