At this point this site is just a social club for like 60 of us. Since this date 5 years ago, we've only had 6 members who have joined that now have over 1000 posts. In the last 5 years we've added 576 members. In the 5 years before that we had 2,692 join up. I think the Cubs being terrible is worth 90+ percent of that decline, however, I think the mega threads are not very conducive to drawing in new members and increasing traffic. If someone was just browsing through and looked at the forum, they might almost think it looks dead due to the lack of threads. My main reason for not liking them has been echoed by others in here, which is that you're just creating a forum within a forum.