I wonder if we don't tend to overrate our own guys and underrate those of other teams? Julio is having a reasonable year (WHIP of 1.20, and excellent K/BB), is young, and has a big arm. Marlins need a strong reliever. Equating Julio with Hawkins is silly, IMO. Penn is 20 years old,, and scouts with a much bigger arm than Marshall, IMO. Bigbie is pretty worthless, but he's athletic unlike Dubois. If Florida considered the analogy to be Dempster, Hill, and Murton, would that look so trivial? Good points all around. However, I believe Marshall is a better prospect than Hill at this point, simply based on age, experience, and control. I wouldn't do that trade, mainly because Lowell would have no position and Burnett would be a rental.