There were plenty of people last year saying that Maddux's option vesting was way down on the list of Cubs problems. They were probably a little quieter last year, just like the critics are quieter this year. *waving* I would have been one of those. Especially since Maddux did a fairly good job the first part of last season as well. Yes, he did give up some HRs, but he did get the job done while Wood and Prior spent time on the DL (kind of like now). Like I've said on at least one other occasion, yes, $9 mil is a lot of money for an aging pitcher who isn't as great as he once was, but he's the ONLY person on the staff who eats up innings and more often than not keeps the team in the ballgame. If anyone "saved" the Cubs last year, it was Maddux (and Z) - keeping the team in the race - but only long enough to get Wood in the bullpen. As for the HOF speculation, there is no way Maddux goes in with a non-Braves cap unless he gets three more Cy's and two or more WS wins with one other team before his playing career is done. EDIT: when I first saw this thread, there were 31 replies. :D I also said that all the Maddux for 9 million freakout, was much ado about nothing. Yes, he's overpaid. But the few million he is overpaid, for one year, wasn't going to have a big impact on the Cubs '06 campaign. It hasn't and won't.