Last year Mulder was a stud over the last three months of the season and pitched credibly in the postseason as well. Probably much better than Haren would have given his inexperience (both starting in the postseason, and in dealing with late season arm fatigue), but that's impossible to really know. At the time, I felt better having Mulder out there than I would have felt having Haren starting. This year, obviously, it's a different story. Haren is pitching better, is younger, and is cheaper. It would be nice having him back, but I still don't mind the gamble that Jocketty took for last year's playoffs. Nobody knew that Mulder would fall right off the map like this at age 28 (he's only three years older than Haren, remember). If Mulder had continued his resurgence from the last three months of the season, Walt would be looking pretty decent. As it is, right now, the deal looks pretty bad. There's still time for another face-saving turnaround though...Mulder blew in the middle of last year two and still salvaged a pretty decent season out of it. Either way, I don't see the Cards signing him to a long term big dollar deal this offseason.