Bingo. People always argue about the MLS vs Europe path. Mention the NCAA route and it's anathema to soccer purists. Fact is, some paths are better than others, but they ultimately won't be what tips the scales. Obviously, I'd love every promising young American to go live in Barcelona and train at La Masia or at Ajax, but what truly matters is [expletive] work ethic. You hear fans and pundits whine about how much time they waste in development by going to play in college and playing seasons in MLS before they go abroad all the time. But just think about Clint Dempsey, Brian McBride and Claudio Reyna, the three non-keeper Americans who we have been able to count on most in big games, who have made the biggest impact on the global club scene and our most respected internationals ever. They didn't train with an elite youth academy. They went to college. They started at the bottom and worked their way to the top. Now, I'm not saying that they wouldn't have been even better had they been raised in a traditional, European youth set up. They probably would have been better. What I'm saying is that what has separated them is their hunger. Pure desire and determination to do the work. They get dropped from teams and were out of favor with managers, but they busted their ass to turn it around. The thing about the youth club setup that works so well other than the technical expertise and experience from the instruction is the competition. Systems like Ajax, Barcelona, Bayern Munich, AC Milan etc are pure football darwinism and even if you're a ridiculous super stud like Lionel Messi or Wayne Rooney when you're young, you'll always have senior players to keep you humble. We don't have that in MLS (we will). When Jozy Altidore was 17-18, even if he wasn't the consistently best player on his team, it was widely apparent that he was as gifted or more gifted than anyone. If you go back to somewhere early in this thread, you'll find a post by me talking about a goal he scored for New York 3 or 4 years ago where he just looked like a man among boys. Beat one defender to the ball, shrugged off another and buried it into the upper 90 from the edge of the box. At 18 he never really had to compete for his career's life. Clint Dempsey, Reyna, McBride; guys like that had supreme competitive desire. Not everyone has that, sometimes you have to learn. Sometimes you're just a kid who gets bad career advice. For every Marc Pelosi who goes to Liverpool, Fabian Hurzeler at Bayern or Jo Gyau at Hoffenheim, who we have yet to see emerge, we've had tons of Kenny Cooper, Jovan Kirovski and Danny Karbassiyoun types who just for whatever reason (injury, work ethic, talent?) who never make it out of their elite academies. For Jozy it certainly won't be talent that holds him back.