Then you haven't been watching Lou for the past 1 1/2. Pie is the rule. Theriot is only playing b/c there is no one else Lou is comfortable with (read, no vet). Barrett was a very dumb baseball payers and an even worse defensive catcher, Soto has produced. And even then it took them almost an entire year of Koye Hill and Rob Bowen to give him a shot. With Lou, if you're a first or second year player you better produce right away and you better not make any mistakes because you only get one shot. He's as old school as they come. The difference between Dusty and Lou is that Lou lives in a reality based world and Dusty doesn't. Your post is illogical and full of baseless spin. I'll take your assertions one at a time, and also point out some stuff you chose to leave out: 1) Theriot didn't get the job because no one else was on the roster. Theriot replaced Izturis, a marginal verteran. 2) Soto replaced veterans. The notion that Soto should have gotten a shot earlier than he did ignores the fact that, up until last season, he hadn't done anything to indicate he would be a good ML catcher. 3) Fontenot played 2B for quite a long time last season and has played quite a bit this season is pite of his struggles at the plate (hitting .230, last I looked). 4) Cedeno is on the team and has played well, getting spot starts at both MIF positions and being sent up to PH in crucial situations. He is blocked by a Theriot, not by some marginal vet like Izturis, Neifi or Macias. 5) Marmol is argauably the most important pitcher on the staff. Lou shows great faith in him, even when he struggles a bit. 6) When Hoff was up he played, and played quite a bit. The only reason he is down now is b/c Ward came off the DL. And who the hell cares if Lou is "old school"? What the hell does that even mean? Just last week he was going on about how good someone's OBP is and how important that is. If "old school" means what I think you intend it to mean, then no, Lou is not "old school". It's such a dumb, throw-away term. Right up there with calling every small, white, MIF'er "gritty".