Which of these lineups would be better? A) The best hitter at each position, put them in any order. or B) The best hitter in each lineup spot, leadoff, 2-hole, third, cleanup etc. Let's see what we get for 2005... A) Chase Utley, Alex Rodriguez, Albert Pujols, Vladimir Guerrero, Manny Ramirez, Andruw Jones, Michael Young, Victor Martinez, pitcher or B) Ichiro Suzuki (CF), Michael Young, Albert Pujols, Manny Ramirez, Alfonso Soriano, Jermaine Dye, Jorge Posada, Bill Mueller, pitcher And I think we all know which of those lineups we'd prefer. A is clearly far and away superior to B. Now that's my problem with the Cubs and Juan Pierre. Build your team by getting the best possible player at each position that you can get, and everything will sort itself out. Not by going after a good lead-off hitter, a good two-hole hitter, a good cleanup man, a good five-spot hitter and so on. It doesn't take a special kind of player to lead-off. Just someone that can get on base and run un-slow. If you have eight players that all get on base and can run un-slow, as many of them hitting for power too as you can muster, then you've got no worries. There's just no need for Juan Pierre types, with a good bunter batting second and so on... DON'T BUILD LINEUPS BY LINEUP POSITION!