No it doesn't, at least not to me. I love Walker, but the man simply cannot field. But neither does Jeff Kent, and he is a questionable HOFer. I am of the school of thought that the team is only as strong as the "Up-the-middle" defense. And right now, the Cubs up the middle defense is PRETTY bad. I love Walker's bat, and has always wanted him on the Cubs going back to his Rockies days, but the Cubs have got to get players who actually can field his position (not necessarily a GG caliber). If the Cubs decide to go with Cedeno at SS, then maybe Walker "shortcomings" at 2B can be overlook, but if the Cubs go with Nomar, or Furcal, or any offensive minded SS, then the Cubs have to find a good glove 2B, who provides decent offensive #'s. We'll have to agree to disagree on this one. I think Nomar (if healthy all year) and Walker up the middle and in the lineup would be just fine. Yes, I would like to improve his defense. I'd take a player with a good bat and good D any day of the week over a player with a good bat and average to below average D. However, if I am choosing between a player with a below average bat and good D, and a player with a good bat and below average D, I'll take player #2 any day.