I'm firmly in the Cashman camp, but by firmly I mean I don't care as long as the guy/girl doesn't have the same rep as Hendry (scouting guy, old school, guts, instinct, personality, etc). I usually love those kind of people and the world definitely needs more people like that, but baseball's going to the suits now. I actually think my second option would be Cherington, which might be sacrilege with the Friedman hype machine chugging along.