snip i assume you watched the game, correct? oh this was kind of funny/dirty: http://yfrog.com/47hycvz I have seen both sequences in full, several times. And watched it again as I am typing this. Carcillo took a little shove near the crease, and Miller gave him a shove/swing. He didn't get hit in the face, Carcillo faked it, and then pretended to be knocked out/flopped, before collapsing into the crease. As for Richards, you cannot seriously think popping an elbow that high is simply "bracing" himself. he got hit in the face by miller and the other guy also grabbed him about the head. carcillo was called for roughing; he didn't do anything during that play that would justify a roughing call. if you think he was faking it, then you call him for diving. you can't call a player for something he didn't do. i should clarify on richards that he did peek over his shoulder and get his elbow up, and he hit kaleta in the face, so a penalty was justified there. but 5 minutes was a terrible call. if that's 5 minutes then every elbowing penalty should be automatic 5 minutes. and part of the frustration is the fact that kunitz' flying elbow, an attempt to injure if there ever was one, is assessed as a two minute minor while richards gets 5. you might as well just not have rules if you're going to apply them so arbitrarily.