no, i'm saying how often he gets a hit doesn't tell me much about how much someone contributes offensively. No but it tells quite a bit For instance if someone can get a hit 35% of the time then he is a good player even if he is a below average power hitter. so far this year, one player has gotten a hit 35% of the time. that's a very limited way to look at things. and seriously, if all of those hits are singles and he's a slow/bad base runner, he doesn't contribute much offensively. average is virtually worthless on it's own, much moreso than OBP or SLG. and he doesn't walk. A .350 hitter who never walks, never gets hits other than singles, and runs the bases poorly is not a particularly good baseball player. But this is completely unrealistic, because a guy is at least going to walk sometimes (no hitter who is clueless about the strike zone is going to hit .350) and at least lace some doubles and the occasional home run. VORP, from BP: