Fantasy Football Incompetence

[TruffleShuffle]

My friend Robert proposed the following trade to, let's call him, Fool:

 

Robert gives up:

B. Roethlisberger

M. Harrison

C. Portis

 

Fool gives up:

T. Romo

M. Colston

C. Benson

 

 

Robert was in pretty poor shape at QB and was willing to downgrade at other positions to get a top fantasy QB.

 

Now Fool is a guy who dropped Randy Moss in week 3 last year, in a 14 team league. He's a nice guy, but basically a dolt when it comes to fantasy football. He's also a pseudo Bears fan. So he rejects the trade because he wants to keep Benson, but replies with the following offer:

 

Robert gives up:

B. Roethlisberger

S. Morris

 

Fool gives up:

T. Romo

L. Johnson

 

 

WTF?!?!? And of course people in our league are too stupid/lazy to vote to reject the trade, so now the one guy has a powerhouse with Portis, Addai and Johnson at RB, Romo at QB and Harrison at WR. Thanks a lot, Fool.

[Vanilla Ice]

well some idiot in my league proposed

 

He gets

Roy Williams

Barber the 3rd

 

I get

Adrian Peterson

Steve Smith

 

This is of course, the week Williams has a bye, Peterson scores 40, and Smith scores 20

[forbez18]

Do you use a commissioner to moderate the league? I know it is a lot of work for one guy to make decisions on what is a fair trade and what is not. Sometimes a trade can look completely uneven and then work out the other way. A few years back I traded Brandon Stokely for a #2 RB I forget who, but the league rejected the trade, and it was the best thing for me as Stokely went on to be a Great #2 WR that year and the other guy really didn't do much. However, that was in Manning's record breaking season.

 

Now we use draft analyzer that we use on scoutfantasyfootball.com and if it shows a huge difference then we bring it up for vote.