I wouldn't have minded seeing Lee a spot or two higher, but I think Z was that high because of his ability to stay healthy, which is invaluable for a pitcher. You're not considered the 11th best player in the league because you can stay healthy. He's the 3rd highest ranked pitcher on the list. All of these pitchers come before Zambrano if I am starting a team: - Jo. Santana - C. Carpenter - J. Peavy - R. Oswalt - D. Willis - J. Beckett Ben Sheets would have been on my list, but he just can't stay healthy. And I'll gamble with Beckett. Santana, maybe. Peavy and Oswalt are about equal to Z. I wouldn't pick any of the rest though. Carp and Beckett have bad injury history. Carp is the reigning Cy Young winner...he's on the list. . Where's Colon on your list :lol: The fact is, the Cards would never turn down a Z for Carpenter trade. Zambrano is one of the most valuable players in the game due to his stuff, statistical history, age and projectability. And as for the Dunn debate, if best "hitter" refers to something other than offensive production, then who cares a about "hitting"? A hitter's job is to produce runs, not hits.