you're so cute when you're coy My neighbor when I was a child was an old woman named Coy. Actually her last name was McCoy, but we all called her Coy. Either way, she was like 70. Other than that, I've never known anyone named Coy. I surely never was called Coy. And please don't say I'm cute....I'm not gay, not that there's anythin wrong with it, I'm just saying I'm not.